Photo: Hans Weingartz, Wikimedia Commons |
What I'm finding less funny is how we can see contemporary use of big data and tracking as part of discipline's creation and use of new knowledges in shaping and maintaining the Normal. Some might also be prone at the moment to substitute "the NSA" for "God" in that phrase of yore-- and it might be even more interesting to speculate about how said agency and those that depend upon and interact with it might have more, and more insidious, ways of corralling so-called (potential) delinquents into the Normal than does any assertion about divine displeasure. What may be a more interesting thought experiment would be to imagine employing Mettray's warning message as the basis for a new interior design pattern for the NSA and for those in league with it. I'm guessing none of the targets, though, would see the humor or the irony in that move-- and, as proven by Google's own legendary appeal to its employees to refrain from evil, you eventually stop seeing what's right in front of your face, much less thinking or caring about the demands it makes or the action it requires.
Was Foucault happy to have revealed the ways in which society often controls its own? I can't offer any thoughts on that question. But my guess is, he knew it would be relevant long after his rock star status was transferred to the next aspirant on the historical-philosophical scene.
*Foucault, of course, has something particular in mind when he talks about discipline/the disciplines-- very generally, a mechanism for achieving docility (adherence to the norm) and maximum productivity, which has at its disposal and continues to produce new forms of measurement, documentation, observation, and so forth. Examples? Medicine, education, criminology,...
No comments:
Post a Comment